Riva Pomerantz
  • Home
  • Who Am I?
  • My Work
  • Upcoming Projects
  • Blog
  • Contact
Write-Off or Write On? 12/27/2009
6 Comments
 
Readers of the world, stamp your feet in protest, raise your voices in loud, tempestuous clamor. You have been accused of a most severe thing, by those who pass judgment with knowing glances and somber, wise noddings of their heads. Your crime, you ask? Apathy toward demanding good writing.

Your face blanches; your heart is momentarily stilled. Or not. Perhaps a brief detour from the melodrama is warranted at this point, in the form of, well, some context. At a recent meeting of some various and sundry writers, one particularly skilled writer raised the point that in the Jewish world, writing is a notoriously under-paid profession. If this is news to you, kind reader, I apologize for possibly shattering any entrancing illusions you may have held...of multi-millionaire frum writers, cavorting in their summer homes on eight-figure salaries, occasionally deigning to pluck the keys of their computers to weave together an article or two. :-)

In the course of the conversation, one writer posited her stalwart theory--nay, flaming indictment--which I alluded to at the beginning of this post, namely that the reason why frum writers are, on a whole, woefully underpaid, is because their readers do not demand excellence. Thus, those who employ the services of these writers are not pressured to raise the bar by hiring only cream-of-the-crop, highly talented writers who could then demand top-dollar for their work. This is her theory; I present it to you, gentle reader, and await your opinion.
Is this really true? Is the public willing to acquiesce to whatever comes their way rather than demand what it truly deserves? And do you think this has any connection whatsoever to the compensation of frum writers?
 


Comments

random guy
12/28/2009 23:01

I know where I live a few people have stopped purchasing Mishpacha magazine due to their (what you call unfounded) anti-kollel slant.

Do they see a difference?
Was this done on purpose to try to open up to the MO world more?
Did they think they would be poseach al shtei seifim?
Do they not feel a difference in the chareidi communities of KS, beitar, BS, and in america, Lakewood etc?

Reply
Riva link
12/30/2009 01:54

Random Guy--I'm not sure if your response is geared toward this blogpost as it seems more apropos to a prior post. I'd like to try to understand what you are asking/saying. Are you suggesting that Mishpacha is poseiah al shtei se'ifim? Does writing up Rabbi Shachter inherently put a magazine on ambiguous footing? I believe the purpose of covering figures in the Modern Orthodox world is to promote ahavas Yisrael and achdus. If that's the purpose, then a fresh set of questions needs to be asked, none of which are mine to answer. Some questions that come to my mind are:

Is the desire to promote achdus and ahavas Yisrael by bringing in articles from beyond the strict confines of the chareidi community in line with ratzon Hashem?

Why are people stopping to purchase Mishpacha? Is it about fear? Is it about ignorance? Is it about deeply rooted beliefs of right and wrong?

Is veering away from a status quo norm inherently a wrong thing to do?

I'm not sure what you mean by your last question. If you could clarify, I'd get a better idea of where you're going with it.

Reply
bikores.blogspot.com
12/30/2009 08:15

I think it's like the preponderance of black clothing being sold in stores catering to frum women. Women may prefer other colors but they have to make do with what is being sold or not buy at all. So too with books, if I like to read, and this is what is available, I'll read it. Practically speaking, how are readers supposed to demand anything?

I think frum writers don't get paid much because the frum market is very small. If publishers aren't going to sell many books, they can't afford to pay top dollar to writers.

Reply
Rose
01/13/2010 05:30

I agree with the above poster as to why frum writers are paid less. I think it has to do with the market.

In what way can I as a reader and consumer demand better writing? I can't afford to pay more for the Jewish books that I do purchase just to have better writing in a smaller market... I will buy what's out there and not count necessarily on the Frum books for my quality reading.

Reply
Freeda
02/22/2010 14:26

Not only is the market much smaller, the writing is not on the same level. It's hard to find quality writing in frum books.

Reply
Riva link
03/09/2010 01:11

Bikores--Definitely the market is smaller, which contributes. The black clothes preponderance seems to me to be more bi-directional. If women really refused to buy black clothes, wouldn't it shift the market into other colors? Instead, women continue to buy black so they don't stick out like, er, the black sheep. But that's the subject of another blogpost!

Rose--You're absolutely right. I really hear you on the money aspect.

Freeda--Now I'm offended :-) Unfortunately, you're right; there is a lot of poor quality writing in the frum world, but there is hope...

Reply



Leave a Reply

    About Riva Pomerantz

    I'm a freelance writer, widely published in Mishpacha Magazine, www.aish.com, amongst others. You can buy my books, Green Fences, Breaking Point, and Breaking Free, at www.targum.com. My serialized story, Charades, is really heating up!

    Archives

    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    May 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009
    June 2009
    May 2009
    April 2009
    March 2009
    February 2009
    January 2009
    December 2008
    November 2008

    Categories

    All
    Adolescents
    Aish
    Blogging
    Chanukah
    Charades
    Color
    Connection To Hashem
    Death
    Fame
    Food
    Friendship
    Greatness
    Green Fences
    Hashkafah
    Homemaking
    Introduction To My Blog
    Israel
    Life
    Media
    Money
    Moshiach
    Music
    Parenting
    Perspective
    Self Esteem
    Self Improvement
    Self Esteem
    Selfimprovement
    Shopping
    Smoking
    Society
    Writing

    RSS Feed


Create a free website with Weebly